Icarus may have been a better name: The ‘Prometheus’ Review

*Warning: There will be Spoilers here*


Now that Prometheus has been out for a few weeks, much has been said about it. Some good, some bad, mostly indifferent. In a way this is a film that was almost as doomed from the start then the crew of the titular ship. The ‘Alien’ franchise has 2 great movies, 1 decent one, and 3 more steaming piles. However, the greatness of those first two really still carry a lot of weight. Although Ridley Scott went as far out of his way as possible to break people’s expectations with the ties to those films, make no mistake about it, this is within the same breath. That serves to the film’s success but also to its downfalls.

Once again, huge spoiler warning. If you haven’t seen it yet, best to come back afterward!


‘Prometheus’ starts on a barren landscape with rolling hills and desolate tundra. A giant shadow looms overhead until we reach a massive waterfall. Standing on the edge we see a large, almost luminescent humanoid take and drink from a strange vial. This liquid rapidly dissolves his DNA as he drops into the water, where new genetic connections are made. This scene is followed by Elizabeth Shaw (Noomi Rapace) finding a cave painting in Scotland that has connections to the exact paintings of other civilizations gapped by centuries. And from there we are off into deep space where discoveries are made, answers are revealed, and things go badly for the crew of the Prometheus.

Once on this new planet, the team discovers the long dead bodies of the Engineers (or Space Jockeys as we have been accustomed to calling them). We see more of the black ooze that killed the Engineer at the beginning of the film. This ooze has the power to end life and create it; making hybrid copies of the things that it touches (wonder how that will come into play later on?).  Soon the crew finds themselves beset by alien creatures, contamination, and all sorts of space drama peril, as a message starts unfolding as to who and what we really are comes to the forefront.

The first half of ‘Prometheus’ was by far my favorite part of the movie. From David the android (played wonderfully by Michael Fassbender) navigates the ship while the rest of the crew is in hyper-sleep. These scenes wonderfully construct this world and bring so much depth and reality to what Scott is composing. Once at LV-223 (the moon sustaining life), the movie really pulls off the feeling of discovery. Everything feels like wide-eyed wonder and magical. The set design based off of H.R. Giger’s work in particular, really brings so much weight and life to the film. This is a film I would have been happy with just sitting back and watching some sort of archeological dig for 2 and a half hours.

That is not what you get in the second half of this film. As much as I can understand that stories, and ones in this universe, follow a structure and need a conflict. That’s not to say this movie doesn’t pull that off, it does have some great creatures and some wonderful moments in it. But it did leave me wishing for more. Once the creatures are awoken, we are left with hypothesis, not answers. While that is all well and good, it makes ‘Prometheus’ feel exactly like what it is aiming for; which is; its own series of films. We learn the Engineers want to kill us off for some reason and that something (we are never told what) stopped them at first. After the black goo hits the fan, and the crew is reduced to a human and an android on a mission to go to yet another planet to ask those higher than the Engineers ‘why are we here, what does it all mean’, I was left wanting more than what I got. I would love to see the continuing series if that is what happens, because there are a lot of questions posed by the film and I’d love to see what route they take.

With that being said: should they continue with this story line, there are some things I would like for those films to NOT do.

I don’t want each film to turn into a hostile alien chase film. Those are fun movies and entertaining, but I’ve seen that before and done better than it is in this film (by the same director). I’d love to see the ‘Prometheus’ series go more in the direction of ‘2001’. This is a film that carries lofty ideas and has some wonderful places it could go, it just needs to not be afraid to go there. I think fans of this series would love to see something more like that than just a retread of what they’ve seen before. Science Fiction is a wonderful genre to highlight and speculate about ourselves and the universe around us, and it’s better when it’s serious and not just survival-horror.

Now, I’ve come down a bit on this movie on what it isn’t; that doesn’t mean I didn’t enjoy it. I thought it was great. I had a blast sitting in the movie theater watching it unfold and a really want to return to it when it is released on DVD. There is a lot of wonder in this film, a lot of great performances, so good thrills, and more than once did I sit there with a smile plastered on my face. Like I said earlier, this is a wonderfully constructed world where the story feels important and familiar. This is a film definitely worth your time and money. It reaches higher than most films of its genre, but it’s wings do end up a little burned. But what it does have is possibility. If this is the beginning, then it’s a journey I can’t wait to go on.

And yes, there is a Xenomorph in this movie. It is born from a woman, born from a giant face hugger, out of the chest of a Space Jockey. I liked it but it didn’t need to be in the film.


The Good: A visually impressive film that builds and expands the universe of its foundation. There are great sights and lots of heavy ideas and themes. If you are fan of sci-fi, this is a must see film. Definitely see this one on the big screen. Wonderful direction and set design.

The Bad: It does not quite reach the levels it was aiming for. Turns too much into a cat and mouse film toward the end. My only other real complaint is the score. It was not for me at all. Anytime the music and main theme was repeated I noticed it and it took me out of the film. I wanted something a little more from it and I don’t know what

Worth to See: Yes. Regardless of my complaints, this is a film that is full of a lot of greatness.


29 thoughts on “Icarus may have been a better name: The ‘Prometheus’ Review

  1. I never wanted to see this film so I’m glad of the spoilers! Hype really bothers me. I far prefer to just go and see things on my own terms, you know? I usually like films that are quite obscure and out there, indie films I guess. The weird ones. Did you ever see ‘The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou’? Love it! Fab soundtrack. Same guy that did Tenenbaums/Rushmore etc. Love it! 🙂

  2. I did really enjoy this film…maybe more while I was watching it. When I left the theater with my husband and friends we all started talking about the questions we had regarding it that were fuzzy, or didn’t make sense, or didn’t seem to fit. I’m like you, I hope they do go on and make more because they left me with a lot of questions after this one.

  3. To me the most engaging character was David, the android. I’m looking to see more of him than the character Elizabeth. I saw this movie focusing on more him than her even when through her eyes. The references to his lack of soul and pinnochio seemed to mark him as the protagonists in perhaps the stories to come…maybe it will slowly focus in on him at the end of all this in the story arc. I see three questions being perhaps beings asked in this movie and the movies to come (perhaps not being answered though)…Why were we made by this race? Why do they want to destroy us now? What determines an entitiy having a soul?

    Side note: I found it very interesting that the ships controls start with a piccolo…I think that says something about there race, good or bad who knows but I’m thinking good. A race that centers their ignition system around music..

    • I also found it odd the switch to Shaw as the main focus, as most of the movie centered around David in it’s own right (and he was the most interesting character). I loved how vague it was by making it seem like he had formed emotion. Excellent acting on Fassbender’s part.

      I also see the Engineers as good, i just want to know more about them and the movie didn’t do that.

  4. The movie sucked cotton balls! I was disappointed by the story line and logical flaws. Why doesn’t Elizabeth’s (she had the same name in The Girl… series as well) helmet shatter when the expendables helmets shatter? For one.

  5. Have not seen it yet. Planning on Sat or Sun morning this coming weekend. I’m avoiding reading too much, but from I’ve been able to see, and from what I have heard, I think your title is right on the mark.

    • This is another example of the marketing hurting a film. All the teasers and trailers and video blogs, while cool, showed too much and raised expectations too high and the movie couldn’t fully live up to everyone’s idea of what ‘Prometheus’ would be. It’s definitely worth to see (though don’t spring for the 3D, doesn’t add much to the movie).

  6. “Anytime the music and main theme was repeated I noticed it and it took me out of the film” YES
    I thought I was the only person that noticed it. I couldn’t put my finger on it but every time that thing played I was irked.

    I think they pretty much have to make this a whole new series of films at this point, it would be horribly disappointing to leave the film where they left it. Lindelof seems to really enjoy philosophizing about things but that seems to translate to TV better than a 2 hour movie.

    • I’ve heard a lot of people say the score was amazing. I cannot understand that. I really disliked it. I can’t even really put my finger on it. Like it wanted to be epic but ended up a parody of epicness is probably the best way I can describe it.

      I feel like they felt pressure to pay fan service by making the second half the creature chase stuff. I don’t mind the tension or suspense but I was hoping for a deeper meaning

  7. I did not like the music. It’s a poor score – would’ve liked to see Elliot Goldenthal come back, he nailed it in ‘3’. While I enjoyed hearing Goldsmith’s ‘Alien’ theme reprised, why on Acheron did it accompany the Weyland hologram scene? Wasted.

    I didn’t come out and say it on ‘Moonwolves’ but you did; ‘2001’. That’s what I was alluding to when I said I saw the next film as a possible classic. Scott doesn’t have to go anywhere near ‘Alien’ again. That notion excited me more than the film I was watching. Trouble is, would the ‘fanboys’ settle for something radically different? I hated the final sequence – the xenomorph – coz it’s basically setting up the Alien species again and I don’t think we need to go in that direction. Of course, dong-head may be saved for a third film…

    I went back to the cinema and watched it again. I have to say, honestly, ‘Prometheus’ didn’t get better with an extra viewing. It’s a good film, that’s all. I too enjoyed the 1st half more than the 2nd. Looking forward to getting it on blu-ray now.

    Agreed about the 3D. Did you see it in RealD? Is RealD different to digital 3D or have I got confused? See, I understood Scott was going down the ‘Avatar’ 3D route… ‘Prometheus’ 3D got nowhere near the same depth of field.

    Excellent review, mate.

    • Thanks man! I’d love to sit and chat about it, Jonah and I will be doing a podcast soon discussing it, think you might have any interest in joining?
      I wished so badly for more of a 2001 and I really do hope the next one goes that direction. I feel like scott felt so underpressure to have ACTION that is why we got the second half
      I’m not sure about the 3d, but i agree, it seemed small, as to Avatar where it felt like it was all around me

      • Sounds very professional.

        I’d better leave thee to it (despite me being able to talk the hind legs off a donkey about anything ‘Alien’). And considering my internet just pisses off consistently without warning – like it just did for 20 minutes.

        But thanks for the offer!

      • no problem man. I’d love to chat with you about the film. maybe you would consider doing a more spoiler ridden take we can discuss (in type) about the movie? love to hear more of your thoughts on it

      • Sounds good to me…

        How are you going about this podcast, by the way? How does that work, technically I mean? And when?

      • it’s like Skype almost or like a teleconference. A bunch of people call into one line and talk on it. I’m not certain exactly when I need to nail that down with Jonah and Conti

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s